If you’ve ever traveled through the southern United States, chances are you’ve come across two iconic sodas – Cheerwine and Big Red. These beloved soft drinks have a dedicated following and are often the subject of friendly debates between fans. So, what’s the difference between Cheerwine and Big Red? Let’s dive in and find out!
First up, let’s talk about flavor. Cheerwine has a unique blend of cherry and spices that give it a distinct taste. It’s slightly sweet with a little kick, making it a popular choice for those who like a bit of boldness in their beverages. On the other hand, Big Red is a cream soda with a vanilla flavor that’s a bit sweeter than Cheerwine. Both sodas contain caffeine, so they’re a great pick-me-up when you need a little boost.
Another difference between Cheerwine and Big Red is availability. Cheerwine is primarily available in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia, while Big Red is most popular in Texas. However, both sodas have a strong cultural significance in the regions where they are popular. Cheerwine is often used in southern cuisine and has become a beloved cultural icon, while Big Red is known for its creative marketing campaigns and was even named the official state soft drink of Texas in 2013.
Here’s a quick chart summarizing the differences between Cheerwine and Big Red:
| Cheerwine | Big Red | |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor | Cherry and slightly spicy | Cream soda with vanilla flavor |
| Color | Burgundy | Bright red |
| Caffeine | Yes, contains caffeine | Yes, contains caffeine |
| Availability | Primarily in the southern US | Primarily in the southern US, most popular in Texas |
| Cultural significance | A beloved cultural icon in the southern US, used in southern cuisine | Popular in Texas, the official state soft drink, known for creative marketing campaigns |
| Sweetness level | Less sweet | Sweeter |
Differences between Cheerwine and Big Red
Origins and History
Origins and History: Cheerwine
Cheerwine is a cherry-flavored soda that was first created in Salisbury, North Carolina in 1917. It was originally called “L.D. Peeler’s Carolina Beverage Corporation” after its founder, but the name was later changed to “Cheerwine” in 1924.
Cheerwine was initially sold only in the Carolinas, but it gradually expanded its distribution to other states in the south and eventually became a beloved regional drink. Today, Cheerwine is still based in North Carolina and is distributed in 20 states, primarily in the southern US.
Origins and History: Big Red
Big Red, on the other hand, has a more mysterious origin story. It was first introduced in Waco, Texas in 1937 by the Big Red, Inc. company. The original recipe was a sweet, bubblegum-like flavor that quickly gained popularity in Texas and surrounding states.
Despite its popularity, Big Red has never divulged the specific ingredients used in its recipe, which has only added to its mystique. In recent years, the company has added new flavors to its lineup, including Big Blue (blue raspberry) and Big Pineapple, but the original Big Red flavor remains the most popular.
Flavor Profile
Flavor Profile: Cheerwine
As mentioned, Cheerwine is a cherry-flavored soda. But it’s not just any cherry flavor – it has a unique, slightly spicy flavor that sets it apart from other cherry sodas. Some people describe it as having a hint of cinnamon or clove, while others say it has a slight almond flavor.
Cheerwine is also notably less sweet than other sodas, which makes it a favorite among people who don’t like their drinks too sugary. However, it’s still a carbonated beverage, so it does have a pleasant fizz to it.
Flavor Profile: Big Red
Big Red’s original flavor is difficult to describe – it’s often referred to as “red cream soda,” but that doesn’t quite capture its unique taste. Some people describe it as having a bubblegum-like flavor, while others say it’s more like vanilla cream soda with a hint of fruitiness.
One thing that is clear, however, is that Big Red is definitely on the sweeter side. If you’re someone who likes their drinks to be syrupy and sweet, you’ll probably love Big Red. However, if you prefer something a bit less sweet, you might find it a bit overpowering.
Packaging
Packaging: Cheerwine
Cheerwine is easily recognizable thanks to its distinctive packaging. The soda comes in a clear glass bottle with a red label featuring the Cheerwine logo, which features a happy, anthropomorphic cherry holding a bottle of soda.
In recent years, Cheerwine has also begun packaging its soda in cans and plastic bottles, but the classic glass bottle is still the most iconic way to enjoy this southern favorite.
Packaging: Big Red
Big Red is also instantly recognizable thanks to its bright red packaging. The soda comes in a can or plastic bottle with the Big Red logo prominently displayed.
However, the company has also experimented with special edition packaging over the years, including limited edition cans featuring sports teams or holidays.
Cultural Significance
Cultural Significance: Cheerwine
Cheerwine is more than just a soda – it’s a cultural icon in the southern US. In fact, the drink is so beloved that it even has its own holiday: the third Saturday in May is known as “Cheerwine Day” in North Carolina.
Cheerwine is also a popular ingredient in southern cuisine. It’s often used in recipes for everything from barbecue sauce to cupcakes to ice cream. If you’re ever in North Carolina, you’ll likely see Cheerwine-flavored products on menus and in stores everywhere you go.
Cultural Significance: Big Red
Big Red doesn’t have quite the same cultural cachet as Cheerwine, but it’s still a beloved soda in the south. In fact, it’s become something of a cultural touchstone in Texas – the state even named it the official state soft drink in 2013.
Big Red is also known for its creative marketing campaigns. In the 1980s, the company aired a series of memorable commercials featuring a jingle that went “kiss a little longer with Big Red.” More recently, they’ve partnered with brands like Taco Bell to create limited edition drinks like the “Mountain Dew Baja Blast Big Red” slushie.
Availability and Distribution
Availability and Distribution: Cheerwine
As mentioned, Cheerwine is primarily distributed in the southern US. It’s most popular in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia, but it’s also available in states like Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee.
If you’re outside of the southern US, you might have a bit of trouble finding Cheerwine. However, soda has gained something of a cult following in recent years, so you might be able to find it in specialty stores or online.
Availability and Distribution: Big Red
Big Red is also primarily distributed in the southern US, although it’s most popular in Texas. However, soda is also available in other states like Louisiana, Oklahoma, and Arkansas.
If you’re outside of the southern US, you might have a harder time finding Big Red than Cheerwine. However, like Cheerwine, Big Red has a dedicated fan base that has helped to spread the word about soda across the country.
Final Verdict: Cheerwine vs Big Red
So which soda is better: Cheerwine or Big Red? Ultimately, it’s a matter of personal preference.
If you’re someone who likes their drinks to be less sweet and a bit spicier, you’ll probably prefer Cheerwine. It’s also a great choice if you’re looking for a soda with a bit of a kick that’s not too overpowering.
On the other hand, if you’re someone who loves a good, sweet soda, you’ll probably prefer Big Red. It’s also a great choice if you’re looking for a soda that’s a bit more unique in terms of flavor.
Either way, both Cheerwine and Big Red are beloved sodas that have become cultural icons in the southern US. If you ever have the chance to try them, be sure to give them a taste and see which one you prefer!
Alternative to Big Red and Cheerwine
If you’re looking for an alternative to Cheerwine and Big Red, here are some options to consider:
- Dr. Pepper – This soda has a unique blend of 23 flavors that sets it apart from other soft drinks. It’s also widely available in the United States.
- RC Cola – RC Cola has a similar taste to Coca-Cola and Pepsi but is often priced lower. It’s also widely available in the southern United States.
- Faygo – Faygo is a regional soda that’s popular in the Midwest and parts of the South. It comes in a variety of flavors, including classic favorites like cola and root beer as well as more unique options like cotton candy and rock & rye.
- Sun Drop – Sun Drop is a citrus-flavored soda that’s most popular in the southern United States. It has a similar level of sweetness to Cheerwine and Big Red.
- Ale-8-One – Ale-8-One is a ginger and citrus-flavored soda that’s popular in Kentucky. It has a distinctive flavor that sets it apart from other soft drinks.
These are just a few options to consider if you’re looking for an alternative to Cheerwine and Big Red. Each has its own unique flavor profile, so be sure to give them a try and see which one you like best!
FAQs
Cheerwine has a cherry flavor with a slightly spicy kick, while Big Red is a cream soda with a vanilla flavor.
Yes, both Cheerwine and Big Red contain caffeine.
Both sodas are primarily available in the southern United States. Cheerwine is most popular in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia, while Big Red is most popular in Texas.
Cheerwine is a beloved cultural icon in the southern US and is often used in southern cuisine. Big Red is known for its creative marketing campaigns and was even named the official state soft drink of Texas in 2013.
Big Red is generally considered to be sweeter than Cheerwine.
Read More:
